Top 100 Baseball Blog

Sunday, May 29, 2016

Philadelphia Athletics' Connie Mack Prosecuted a Heckling Fan

Heckling has been a part of the baseball experience since the earliest days. Some fans believe that paying for a ticket gives them a right to razz players, both opposing and their own, if they feel it is deserved. This is certainly not one of the more pleasant aspects of the game, and one time Hall-of-Fame manager Connie Mack once decided he had enough and had one particularly aggressive fan arrested for the negative impact he was having on his Philadelphia Athletics.

The city of Philadelphia is well known in the sports world for having some of the most hard-nosed fans. This reputation is supported by an infamous incident in 1968 when even Santa Claus was booed at a Philadelphia Eagles football game. However, the origins for such behavior go back even further and are highlighted by the case of Harry Donnelly and the Athletics.

Bill “Good Time Bill” Lamar was a left-handed sweet- hitting outfielder. A .330 career batting average in the minor leagues made him a valuable major league commodity. Although he reached the big leagues in 1917 with the New York Yankees at the age of 20, it wouldn’t be until 1924, when Mack traded for him (also sending a reported $30,000 in the deal—a princely sum for the time), that he became a regular, hitting .330 in 87 games that year, and .356 in 138 games in 1925.

Unfortunately, Lamar did not turn into a star. He dropped off to a .284 batting average in 1926 and was more of a platoon player in 1927. It was that year that the outfielder seemingly fell out of favor with Mack. In early June it was reported that the team was trying to trade him to the Chicago White Sox for first baseman Earl Sheely, himself a former hitting star who had fallen on tough times.

Although Lamar was hitting .299 in 84 games, he was placed on waivers on August 7, 1927. Reports indicated the move was predicated by the player’s inability to follow team training rules. This was borne out in his numbers, as he hit .337 during the first two months of the season, spanning 42 games, but fell to just .252 the rest of the way—over another 42 games, obviously losing playing time because of his lack of production. Another theory as to what led to his downfall was the incessant heckling, particularly by one Harry Donnelly.

Donnelly was a 26-year-old Philadelphia native who enjoyed going to Athletics games and sitting in the left field stands, right behind where Lamar played most often. He liked needling players in a loud voice that was described as having the “resonance of a three-mile loud speaker,” but his actions were generally considered more offensive than funny. He was even kicked out of one 1926 game when umpire George Hildebrand had ordered him escorted from Shibe Park.

History repeated itself again on August 10, 1927, when umpire Brick Owens grew tired of Donnelly’s incessant baiting and stopped the game to have police remove him from the park. After the game, the arbiter explained he took such extreme action because he found the heckling so objectionable. “The American League has always striven to make baseball a clean game of rowdyism and one that ladies might attend without fear of hearing or seeing anything objectionable… and when a fan goes beyond the pale of common decency and shouts remarks that reek with filth and vileness, then it is time to interfere. Baseball can be enjoyed without that sort of rooting and it can get along without the type of man whose mouthings are full of oaths an indecencies. I’ll have them run out of the park as fast as I can spot them.”

Despite the multiple run-ins over his actions, Donnelly continued coming to games and apparently didn’t learn any lessons. On September 15th, he was up to his same schtick as the Athletics hosted the Chicago White Sox, but this time Mack noticed and had police remove him from the stadium and arrest him for disturbing the peace.

Mack, who had seen his players harassed by a number of fans over the season decided enough was enough and went to court to pursue the charge against Donnelly. Facing the judge, the manage testified that “Yesterday, Mr. Donnelly rode third baseman Sammy Hale until he had him so nervous he would have missed the ball had one been hit to him. In this game an error might have meant defeat (Philadelphia did prevail 5-4 but it is interesting to note that Hale was removed after two at-bats in favor of Chick Galloway).

Continuing, Mack laid the blame for Lamar’s demise squarely at the feet of Donnelly. “Lamar was one of the best outfielders I ever had. But a group of fans, of which this man was the ringleader, kept riding him until he wasn’t any good to me and I had to trade him away.

The hammer was truly dropped in Mack’s closing remarks, as he told the judge, “It seems this young man pays his $1.10 to come and ride the players. Why doesn’t he save it and meet them outside aft the game? We want him to stay away from the park.”
Donnelly refuted Mack’s charges, claiming that he didn’t heckle players but rather attended games to cheer the team on to win. The judge, allegedly an Athletics fan himself, sided with the manager and held Donnelly on $500 bail with the additional threat that he would impose further sanctions if the young man was cited again for “handing out raspberries.”

One can only surmise that the judgment was enough to have Donnelly adjust his behavior, as no further record exists of him causing trouble at Athletics games. Nevertheless, there are some important things to note about the case:

The heckling may have gotten to Lamar but probably not in the way that history remembers. With his decline being attributed to the constant riding, the assumption is that he lost his confidence. However, he was known for his temper (once suspended for his role in a fist fight while with the Louisville Colonels) and may have instead had a hard time concentrating because of how he was triggered.

Lamar was initially picked up on waivers by the Washington Senators but was quickly cut loose again after trying to hold out for a $1,000 bonus to join the team. He played 85 games for Newark in the International League the following season, batting a modest .271 in 85 games and getting himself suspended twice. He never played professional ball again after that, done at the age of 31.

The numbers also don’t suggest that Lamar was long-suffering at the hands of overly aggressive Philadelphia fans. He hit .321 during four seasons with the team, and his home/road batting average splits were .317/.339 (1924), .376/.330 (1925), .287/.281 (1926), and .272/.312 (1927).

The Athletics were good in 1927. Although they finished 19 games behind the New York Yankees, they won 91 games and were a stellar 50-27 at home, on their way to a second place finish.

Despite his stated aversion to heckling, it has been alleged by some, including Hall-of-Fame outfielder Larry Doby, that the Athletics paid fan(s) to heckle opposing players during Mack’s tenure running the team.

Regardless of the impact heckling had on the demise of Lamar’s career, this is one of the more interesting tidbits of baseball history. Not only does it stand out for its unusual nature, the incident is also in contrast to the image many may have of Mack. Certainly, it is an episode that will never been seen again.

You can check me out on Facebook or follow me on Twitter @historianandrew

Friday, May 27, 2016

Boston Red Sox: 4 Under the Radar Prospects

The Boston Red Sox have enough top prospects to keep fan publications and websites interminably churning out content singing their praises. Despite the blue chippers that dot the team’s farm system there is also an extraordinary amount of secondary talent. These are players who may not be as well known as some of their counterparts but could wind up matching or surpassing them when it is all said and done.

With the minor league season now in its second month, let’s take a look at a player from each active level of the minor leagues for the Red Sox who is producing at a level high enough to earn them entry into the conversation of the team’s most coveted prospects, despite the lack of fanfare.

First Baseman Josh Ockimey, Single-A Greenville: The 20-year-old left-handed batter had a slow start to his career. After being taken in the fifth round of the 2014 draft, he went on to hit just .188 in his inaugural season, and followed that up with 78 strikeouts in just 229 at-bats last year.

Playing in his first year of full-season ball in 2016, Ockimey has taken his game to a new level in the early going. Appearing in 41 games, he is hitting .288 with eight home runs and 23 RBIS. While he has whiffed 41 times, the 37 walks he has drawn are an encouraging sign pointing to increased patience at the plate. If he continues to improve this dramatically, the Red Sox may have a bonafide slugging prospect on their hands.

First Baseman Nick Longhi, High Single-A Salem: A 30th-round selection of the team in 2013, he only lasted that long in the draft because his commitment to LSU had raised questions about his signability. Still just 20, he is now in his third professional season and has shown himself to be quite the promising hitter. After batting .330 in 2014 and .281 last year, he is off to a strong start in 2016, posting a .296 average with 12 doubles and 33 RBIs in 42 games.

The right-handed hitter has a solid build (6’2” and 205 pounds) but has not seen his power develop yet. He is without a home run this season and has just eight in over 800 professional plate appearances. However, there’s no reason to think this won’t come as he matures, and his barrage of doubles this year is a promising step in that direction.

Starting Pitcher Justin Haley, Double-A Portland: There are some factors working against the right-handed pitcher. Chief among them is that he is already 25 and is working in his third season at this level. However, there is also plenty to like.  The 2012 sixth rounder was solid in his first three seasons before bombing last year with Portland, to the tune of a 5-16 record with a 5.15 ERA in 27 starts.

Despite repeating the level this year, you can’t stay Haley’s start hasn’t been impressive. In nine starts, he is 3-3 with a 2.68 ERA and has struck out 44 batters in 43.2 innings while yielding a solitary home run. He doesn’t have overpowering stuff but there’s enough there where he could be a real major league contributor as he continues to learn how to pitch effectively with what he does have in his arsenal.

Relief Pitcher Kyle Martin, Triple-A Pawtucket: These days, Triple-A is where most teams stash their organizational depth but not a lot of true prospects. Of course, that’s not a hard and fast rule. The 6’7” 25-year-old right-handed Martin has steadily progressed through the team’s farm system since being a ninth-round selection in 2013.

Although his low-90s fastball is nothing special in this day and age of gas throwers, he has a changeup that describes as a “potential plus offering, true out pitch at the big league level.” He has used that throughout his professional career to average a strikeout an inning.

Although he had problems with the long ball earlier in his career, he permitted just three in 46 innings last year, and has yet to allow one in 23 innings in 2016. However, he has struck out 30 batters and issued just three walks (with a 3.52 ERA). If the Red Sox need another hand in their bullpen in the near future, Martin may very well get the call to see if his success will translate on a big league level.

You can check me out on Facebook or follow me on Twitter @historianandrew

Wednesday, May 18, 2016

Greatness in the Shadows: Larry Doby and the Integration of the Amerircan League- A Review

Jackie Robinson is one of the two or three most commonly known figures in baseball of all time. This is due in part to his Hall-of-Fame playing career and to him integrating the game when he joined the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1947. Not nearly as much attention has been paid to the man who came right after him and became the first black player in the American League—Larry Doby.  Seeking to remedy this is Douglas M. Branson’s Greatness in the Shadows: Larry Doby and the Integration of the American League (University of Nebraska Press, 2016).

Branson contends that Doby has been largely ignored when the platitudes are doled out about the best and most influential players in baseball history. Although the former outfielder is also in the Hall of Fame (but not until 1998; nearly 40 years after he retired from playing), this contention is entirely accurate.

The bulk of Greatness in the Shadows is an effort to bolster Doby’s legacy. In addition to discussing his reputation as being a good person at length, there is an examination of his statistics, which are very good but pale in comparison to many of his Cooperstown brethren because his career ended somewhat abruptly in his mid-30s, as he was slowed by injuries.

Some of Branson’s arguments are simple yet totally valid. As he points out, everybody remembers who was first but rarely recall or care who was second. Doby faced similar challenges and barriers as Robinson, debuting with the Cleveland Indians just months after his National League counterpart, but received just a fraction of the attention—both in the moment and in remembrance.

While this book has plenty of positive notes, it also goes off the tracks in places. In an effort to canonize Doby, Branson leaves no stone unturned. This includes examining some of the outfielder’s peers and offering arguments of why they may have received credit that detracted from Doby. When talking about Willie Mays and how the legendary outfielder dealt with segregation as minor league player, he suggests the experience may not have been as bad some historians/writers may have you believe because the food at the boarding houses, where black players had to stay instead of at a hotel with their white teammates, was “far superior to hotel fare of the time.” This seems like an unnecessary and ineffective way of making his argument.

Some of Branson’s other arguments are compelling but fly in the face of popular baseball history. Doby toiled in relative obscurity in large part because he played the bulk of his career in Cleveland, which was a secondary media market. He was also frequently overshadowed by other players who were either more flamboyant or held in higher regard by journalists. It is noted that pitcher Satchel Paige (a teammate of Doby) has much higher renown despite a reputation for selfishness, and having a playing record that he does not believe stands up to the legend (i.e. a losing career major league record of 28-31).

Outfielder Mickey Mantle is another example proffered in the case for Doby. While Branson does not deny he was a great player, he also believes his gregarious nature enhanced his legacy, such as exaggerated home run distances, and elevated him to god-like status to the detriment of Doby.

Stat heads might argue that Doby was a great player who just doesn’t measure up numerically to the all-time greats. Unfortunately, Branson largely passes on this area, admitting he doesn’t fully understand newer advanced statistics, and also claiming the outfielder played in more of a pitching era where advanced statistics are not as readily available. However, a quick review of a site like gives a lot of good information demonstrating Doby was a titan in his day.

Ultimately, Branson has put a lot of good research and thought into supporting Doby as deserving a greater place in baseball history. Not all of his contentions hit the mark but there is plenty to chew on, and any baseball fan would do well to learn more about the dynamic outfielder who helped transform the game.

Disclaimer: I was provided with a free advanced copy of this book, but received no payment or other consideration for this review.

You can check me out on Facebook or follow me on Twitter @historianandrew

Sunday, May 15, 2016

Did Bony Knees Cost Lou Gehrig a Hollywood Career?

Lou Gehrig is an iconic figure in baseball history, both for his legendary career with the New York Yankees as a slugging first baseman, and because of his tragic death from an eponymous disease at the age of 37. Despite his exploits on the field, he nearly had another star turn—that of Hollywood actor. At one point he was actually poised to assume the role of Tarzan in the movies but was ultimately passed over; possibly due to knobby knees.

The Iron Horse captivated the baseball world during his 17-year run with the Yankees. He walloped the baseball to the tune of a .340 career batting average with 493 home runs, 1,995 RBIs and six World Series championships. Having studied at prestigious Columbia University, he was more educated, and perhaps as a consequence, more taciturn than other stars of the day, especially his teammate Babe Ruth. Accordingly, he did not receive the same amount of attention when it came to the cross-branding some like the Bambino did with baseball and the burgeoning Hollywood business. However, his big break nearly came in 1936, when he was 33 and coming off an MVP season and there was a search for the next Tarzan.

Johnny Weismuller, a chiseled winner of multiple Olympic gold medals as a swimmer, created a lucrative secondary career playing Tarzan in a number of successful movies. After he decided to work on other projects, a replacement was sought. Christy Walsh, Gehrig’s business manager, knew an opportunity when he saw it and pushed for his client to be given the role.

In an effort to boost his candidacy, Gehrig went public with his desire to don the loin cloth of fame. When asked if he was afraid of animals, he played up his baseball experience and his flair for the dramatic, exclaiming, “No! At least I’m not afraid of Tigers—I’ve faced many of ‘em in 12 years of baseball—but those Lions, well, we’ll have to wait and see.”

Sex was not discussed as openly as it is today but was still an integral part of selling movies. When Walsh first contacted producer Sol Lesser about getting Gehrig a screen test, one of the first things they did was ask for more revealing photographs of the slugger, as the only frame of reference they had as to how he might look were the pictures of him in his baggy baseball uniform. “I guess the public’s entitled to a look at my body,” Gehrig acknowledged after news of this spread.

Walsh was unabashedly brash in promoting his client, telling reporters, “Lou’s got everything to go over big in the movies. He stands six-feet-one and weighs 210 pounds. If he gets a chance with lions and tigers there’ll probably be a scarcity of those species after he gets through with them. The next move is up to Hollywood.”

Gehrig was asked who he’d like to have as a leading lady. Although he admitted actress Irene Dunne was his favorite, he did say “I could act much better with my wife in my arms.” When the matter of matching the sex appeal of Weismuller was brought up, Gehrig let that one go by, simply stating, “I’ll leave that up to you fellows and the ladies—If I get the chance.”

Initially, it appeared that Gehrig had nabbed the role. Walsh cryptically told reporters, “Nothing definite has been done but the possibilities have been discussed and Gehrig will be glad to consider the details, if and when they develop.” The papers even started speculating how much money would coax the first baseman on to the big screen.

In late October, 1936, a deal seemed imminent but then quickly went south. The press had printed a photo of Gehrig in his Tarzan leopard cloth dress, wielding a cudgel and making a “jungle call.” Although the world-class athlete had a phenomenal physique, his less-developed knees were allegedly noticeable right away by the Hollywood set who needed to make sure that their next scantily clad hero was unimpeachable when it his level of studliness.

No less than Edgar Rice Burroughs, the original author of Tarzan, went public with his gallon of gasoline he threw on the fire. He sent the aspiring actor a chilly telegram, confirming he didn’t think he had what it took. “Having seen several pictures of you as Tarzan and paid about $50 for newspaper clippings on the subject, I want to congratulate you on being a swell first baseman,” the writer wired sarcastically. Sadly, Hollywood decided to go in another direction with a different actor (Olympic decathlete Glenn Morris) and left Gehrig to continue his career on the baseball diamond.

Gehrig was purported to claim he was the one who turned the role down because being in costume made him feel “too naked.” As a consolation prize, the movie studio gave him a contract “to appear in other pictures.” This led to just one movie role—though a starring one. He received top billing in the 1938 film, Rawhide, whose plot is described by IMDB as “Baseball superstar Gehrig is one of several ranchers being coerced by a bunch of bandits. His sister and her lawyer/lover organize the ranchers.”

It’s indisputable that Lou Gehrig was a much better baseball player than actor. However, he may have gotten a chance to prove otherwise if his apparently non-shapely knees didn’t prevent him from taking over a legendary Hollywood franchise.

You can check me out on Facebook or follow me on Twitter @historianandrew

Sunday, May 8, 2016

Bill Sarni: A Baseball Career Interrupted

Former catcher Bill Sarni had immense ups and downs during his 13-year playing career; perhaps more of a disparity than anyone before him or since. A teen-aged phenom, he started in the Pacific Coast League as a 15-year-old and ultimately made himself into a solid big league receiver. Unfortunately, his story was not to be a happy one, as he was forced to retire at the age of 29 due to a heart attack suffered while playing pepper with teammates before a spring training game.

A native of Los Angeles, Sarni was the size of a full-grown man before most and attracted the interest of the local Los Angeles Angels (affiliated with the Chicago Cubs) in 1943. This was due in equal parts to his ability, the baseball talent drain during that time because of World War II, and because the team lost two catchers in quick succession to injury. He settled in quickly, hitting a home run in his first at-bat and by the end of the season was the team’s starting catcher. This was no ordinary minor league team either. They ultimately finished with a 110-45 record and had a roster packed with future major leaguers, including the likes of Andy Pafko and Ken Raffensberger.

The right-handed hitting Sarni more than held his own during his inaugural season, hitting .229 with a home run in 33 games. He continued to improve with age, even hitting .295 in 105 games as a 17-year-old in 1945.

Although, he did not put up star numbers, he continued to progress as a good defensive catcher with a decent bat. For whatever reason, it took him a bit longer to break into the majors, but he finally got his shot in 1951 with the St. Louis Cardinals.
Sarni finally stuck as a major league regular in 1954 with the Cardinals. The 26 year-old, more than a decade after he started his career, emerged as a borderline star behind the plate. In 123 games, he hit an even .300 with 9 home runs and 70 RBIs. He also nabbed an impressive 56 percent of the base runners attempting to steal on him. Although he followed that up with more modest numbers the next year, he was finally established.

Mid-way through the 1956 season, the catcher was involved in a nine-player trade between the Cardinals and the New York Giants that sent him east. He struggled a bit in his new surroundings but still hit a combined .254 with a career-high 10 home runs and 45 RBIs in 121 games. He was strong as ever against the run, gunning down 45 percent of runners.

Looking to start off the 1957 season on a good foot, the catcher instead encountered tragedy that spelled the end of his career. On February 27th, while playing pepper with some teammates during the team’s first spring training work out, he collapsed with what would be diagnosed as a heart attack. Since he was just 28 at the time, doctors were initially reluctant at making that conclusion, but the subsequent tests bore out the sobering news.

Giants’ President Horace Stoneham told the press “The doctors told me Bill is the second youngest man he ever treated for a heart attack. They said the attack was similar to the one suffered by President Eisenhower. Sarni will be able to live normally otherwise but they told me he never will be able to play baseball again.”

Stoneham was magnanimous in the wake of Sarni’s hospitalization, vowing to employ him as a coach as soon as he was well enough in order to earn him enough service time to qualify for baseball’s five-year pension requirement. This was a promise he kept after his former backstop was released from the hospital a month after his initial admittance.

Despite seeing his career end in the cruelest of ways in the midst of his prime, Sarni picked up the pieces and took up coaching. Towards the end of the 1957 season, he explained, “Some people may feel sorry for me but I consider myself the luckiest guy in the world just being around the boys again and getting a chance to remain in baseball… I’ve thought about catching again but I came to realize there were two important factors to be considered. First, I have a responsibility to my family, my wife and my little boy and girls. Second, who would sign me to play? They’d be taking a big chance. The Giants have been wonderful to me.”

Given a new lease on life, Sarni did not become a baseball lifer. Instead, as reported by the Baseball Necrology, he became a general partner in a brokerage firm in St. Louis. Sadly, he passed away in 1983 from another heart attack at the young age of 55. In parts of five major league seasons, he appeared in 390 games, hitting .263 with 22 home runs and 151 RBIs.

Although he didn’t get to finish playing on his own terms, Sarni made his mark on the game, which is more than most can say. Once a hotshot whiz kid, he never became a super star but was well on his way to a solid career before being knocked out of the game by his heart. It’s safe to say baseball has never seen another player with a journey to the majors like him before or since. 

You can check me out on Facebook or follow me on Twitter @historianandrew

Wednesday, May 4, 2016

5 Things About the 2016 Boston Red Sox That Aren’t Being Talked About Enough

After finishing the 2015 season in last place, the Boston Red Sox look much better this year, currently on a pace for 93 wins. While some things have gone very well, there are others that have not. Despite the chatter that seems to perpetually swirl around the team, some things haven’t received the attention they deserve. Here are five of them (keeping in mind the season is only about a sixth of the way over):

The Way Outfielder Chris Young is Being Used: Signed by the Red Sox this past offseason, the veteran right-handed hitter figured to be the fourth outfielder, getting the bulk of his playing time against lefthanders because of his severe career splits (.224/.292/.410 BA/OBP/SLG against righties and .263/.362/.474 against southpaws). His struggles against right-handed pitchers have become particularly pronounced in recent seasons, as evidenced by his combined .211 batting average against them in his last three seasons entering 2016.

Given Young’s strengths and weaknesses are as defined as any player on the roster, it’s been surprising to see him getting so much playing time thus far against his right-handed nemeses. He has fared predictably, collecting just two hits and eight strikeouts in his 17 at-bats against them, compared to 3-for-13 with just two whiffs against lefties. The Red Sox may not have faced a ton of left-handed starting pitcher so far on the young season but that’s no reason to put Young in situations where he has less of a chance to help the team.

Jackie Bradley Jr. Has Arrived: After several years of struggling to transition from a 2011 first-round draft choice to a major league regular, it appears the 26-year-old outfielder has finally made the leap. Although he may not be a star, he has developed into quite a useful player, contributing terrific defense and enough with the bat to make him a solid starter. In 25 games this year he has hit .276 with an American League leading four triples, a home run and 13 RBIs. He has also cut back a bit on his strikeouts, whiffing about once every four at-bats instead of the once every three at-bats during the earlier part of his career.

The Weird Start of Hanley Ramirez: After a disappointing 2015 season, and a nightmare of a time playing outfield, Ramirez impressed with a relatively seamless transition to the team’s starting first baseman. While he has worked hard and not been a distraction, he is a mixed bag so far at the plate. Although he is hitting a respectable .284, he has just two home runs and walked an uncharacteristic four times against 25 strikeouts (which is putting him on pace for the highest rate in his career—approximately once every four at bats).

However, his .351 BABIP is a bit higher than his .328 career rate, but not enough to scream regression is ahead. His 36.7% Hard Percentage (balls put in play hit hard) is also above his career rate. Still just 32, the physical specimen should still be more or less in his prime, so the numbers suggest he may be on the verge of breaking out in the near future.

Heath Hembree May Have Locked Down a Bullpen Spot: The 27-year-old right-hander has been on the Boston-Pawtucket yo-yo the past couple of years but has been lights out since being called up to the Red Sox this year. In four relief appearances, spanning nine innings, he has permitted just five hits and a lone walk while striking out 11. His fastball has jumped a tick (now averaging about 94 MPH) from when he first reached the majors in 2013 with the San Francisco Giants. His success in the long relief role has been particularly valuable because of the inconsistencies of the starting rotation.

Boston’s Offense is Flourishing Because of Small Ball; Not the Long Ball: Entering this season, hopes were high that the team would field a strong lineup. Although they have produced handsomely, how they have done so is a bit different than most might have expected. Currently, the Red Sox lead the American League in runs (135), batting average (.280), doubles (67), triples (9), and are tied with the Kansas City Royals for the lead in stolen bases (22). However, the team is tied for second-to-last in home runs (22).

Boston lineups in recent years have been headlined by sluggers who were more apt to put a game out of reach with a three-run home run than by maintaining a rally by taking an extra base. The rise of talented youngsters like Mookie Betts and Xander Bogaerts, who have more well-rounded games than big power, has led to this shift. With designated hitter David Ortiz playing in his final season, it’s possible that the team will continue to find even more ways to score runs in the coming years than putting balls over the fence.

Although the season has just entered its second month, there’s already a lot to chew on for fans of the Red Sox. As things continue to play out, there are a lot of things flying under the radar as the team continues to find its identity and see what they can accomplish as a unit in 2016.

You can check me out on Facebook or follow me on Twitter @historianandrew

Sunday, May 1, 2016

Man Versus Ball: A Review

George Plimpton was an author best known for participating as an amateur in sporting events and writing about his experiences.  His perspective and unique writing style exposed an entire new genre of sports journalism. Although he passed away in 2003, his influence remains, as evidenced by Jon Hart’s Man Versus Ball: One Ordinary Guy and His Extraordinary Sports Adventures (University of Nebraska Press, 2013).

In a very Plimptonian way, Hart documents a number of experiences he has had in the sporting world. These include working (for years) as a vendor at major league baseball games; playing semi-pro football; amateur caddying; working for several years as a ball boy at the U.S. Open; and professional wrestling.

Hart’s most interesting venture is his vending, which began as a writing assignment but continued well past that as an actual job. The politics of the trade, along with the little things most people would never think of when buying a hot dog or cotton candy at a game (taking time to find proper currency to give to the customer may increase the likelihood of simply being told to keep the change).

It may be a matter of self efficacy but Hart spends much more time discussing the challenges he faces when working with each experience than the successes. In particular, his time as a player for the Brooklyn Mariners, a semi-pro football team, and his foray into wrestling did not come naturally to him.

In most cases, instead of using real names, Hart comes up with nicknames for the people he interacts with during his adventures. This proved a little difficult to keep up with who was who but ultimately didn’t detract too much from the stories. It would have also been helpful to have a bit more insight into his professional writing and how much that impacted his decisions to immerse himself in these experiences.

A lot of people casually dream about participating in sports, professional or otherwise, but seldom go to the lengths Hart did to find out what all the fuss is about. He writes in an easy style that engages the reader, and acts as a conduit to let us all know what it’s like to do such things as sling hot dogs in Shea Stadium or get clotheslined in a wrestling match. I’m more than happy to let him experience them for me but am also entertained by reading about how he came to have such an eclectic résumé.

Disclaimer: I was provided with a free advanced copy of this book, but received no payment or other consideration for this review

You can check me out on Facebook or follow me on Twitter @historianandrew